Can't wait to download the latest new songs from your favourite singers and bands? Find out release dates right now.
Legal Challenge To Fluoridation Plan
A health authority's been accused in the High Court of unlawfully attempting to force through the fluoridation of Southampton's tap water.
The legal challenge was brought by Southampton resident Geraldine Milner, backed by local campaign groups.
Ms Milner's counsel David Wolfe told a judge that, if the scheme goes ahead, the mother of three teenagers would be left "with no choice but to drink water to which fluoride has been added''.
As opponents of fluoridation demonstrated outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, Mr Wolfe said approximately 195,000 people in Southampton and parts of south-west Hampshire "would have fluoride added to their water whether they liked it or not''.
He told Mr Justice Holman this was contrary to Government policy that no new fluoridation schemes should be introduced unless it could be shown that the local population was in favour.
The South Central Strategic Health Authority (SCSHA) used statutory powers to instruct Southern Water, the local water provider, to go ahead with fluoridation in February 2009 to improve dental health.
The controversial decision came after 72% of those who responded to public consultation opposed fluoridation, with just 28% in favour.
An opinion poll commissioned by the SCSHA produced a narrower result, with 38% against the scheme and 32% in favour and 29% "don't knows''.
Mr Wolfe accused the SCSHA of failing in its legal obligation to properly assess the cogency of the arguments for and against mass fluoridation.
Mr Wolfe said today's application for judicial review was not about the actual merits and health arguments over fluoridation, which were "not all one way by any means''.
It was about the legality of the compulsory scheme, the first of its kind in the UK for 20 years.
Mr Wolfe said: "Four out of five local authorities and three out of four local MPs expressed their opposition within the consultation process.''
He added: "Ms Milner is in good company, whether she is right or wrong.''
The health authority is opposing Ms Milner's legal challenge.
In a two-day hearing, John Howell QC is arguing on behalf of the SCSHA that the authority was required to make a decision on the merits of the scheme, having taken into account local opposition.
But the authority was not legally bound to give effect to whatever the majority of consultees thought, one way or the other.
James Eadie QC, appearing for Health Secretary Andrew Lansley, is supporting the SCSHA's stance.
Arriving at court today, Ms Milner said her family had no need of fluoride in their water, which the authority particularly wanted to introduce to prevent dental decay in children.
Ms Milner said:
"We do not wish to have it.
"What has not been listened to is that there are cheaper, thoroughly researched and proven, effective ways of targeting children who are at risk of dental decay.''
The case today was not about the safety of fluoride, but about whether the SCSHA had acted legally in making its decision.
"It is about whether an unelected body have the right to do this when 72% of respondents to the consultation said no.
"It is about Southampton residents' fundamental freedom of choice over their bodies and rights to democracy and justice.''
Elizabeth McDonagh, chairman of the National Pure Water Association, which campaigns against fluoridation, described it as a very important case because of its general implications for democracy.
Ms McDonagh said:
"Politicians both in Parliament and outside Parliament have said over the years that fluoridation would never be imposed on a community - and yet SCSHA is doing just that after they had a consultation with the public in which 72% of the 10,000 responses from the local community came out against fluoridation.''
A phone poll supposed to reflect the views of a mix of the local population also opposed fluoridation, even though by a reduced margin.
"It is absolutely clear, the SCSHA wholly ignored local people's views,'' said Ms McDonagh.
Stephen Peckham, chairman of Hampshire Against Fluoridation, said there was ``huge controversy'' over water fluoridation.
"Other countries, including Canada, Ireland and now even the US, are actually lowering the amount of fluoride.''
This was because of health concerns, particularly over dental fluorosis, in which tooth enamel was damaged by too much fluoride.
There were other health concerns, although medical sources had conceded not enough was known about either the effectiveness of fluoride, or the safety of fluoride in water.
Mr Peckham added that strategic health authorities were facing abolition, and the SCSHA scheme was likely to be the last one to be permitted by such an authority.
"In just over a year's time it will be up to local authorities to take over these responsibilities,'' he said.
"Everybody elected democratically in the local area is against it. Local people are against it, but the SCSHA is determined to go ahead.
"The SCSHA has put aside £400,000 to fight their case after already spending over £500,000 on the consultation itself.
"An enormous amount of public money has been spent, but I cannot see there is any value.''
Recently Played Tracks
On Radio: Toni Phillips
4pm - 7pm
More music news
From 'Pray' to their newest single 'These Days' - EVERY hit the fans wanted was in there!
Jake, Lewi, Danny and Charley revealed that they are back in the studio working on new music - and Charley got needy when they had a break!
Find out which artist takes their roast dinner on stage with them as Fuse, Tinie and Aston play Capital’s Question-a-balls.
Bieb's proves he's all grown up as he drops a teaser clip from the steamy video of his brand new song.
Rixton’s front man has stuck up for Perrie after Zayn apparently broke up with his Little Mix fiancée by text message - and he's setting her up with his band mate!
So with the VMA's coming up this Sunday, there's only ONE question everyone's asking... will Zayn Malik make an appearance, and even possibly perform?!
He helped them get engaged so it's only right Jake and Jesy Nelson would have Ed sing at their wedding - if they can afford his fees!
The 'Black Magic' stars have made an exciting reveal of the next new track from 'Get Weird'.
After our world exclusive check out the AMAZING lyric video for the return of Justin Bieber.
Check out Calum, Ashton, Mikey and Luke in action in their NEXT new smash.
Check out ALL the amazing stars set to perform at the event in August... and get your tickets!
Find out who Adele's been working with on her top-secret third studio record.
Mr. Malik has the backing of Michael's older brother... and he wants to work with him on new music!
From the One Direction lads to Ariana Grande and Rita Ora, the hottest names in hit music are right here in our new TV advert!
The 'She's Kinda Hot' star takes the spotlight as we run down ALL the reasons we love the cheeky Aussie star.
The hip-hop duo return with an INCREDIBLE new song which has gone down a treat with Capital listeners.
Ever wondered what Harry, Louis, Liam and Niall would look like on the big screen? THIS is what it would look like…
All of our Friends dreams have come true – ‘Phoebe’ is the latest star to join Taylor on stage for an EPIC duet of ‘Smelly Cat’.
Ed's finally cleared everything up after a HUGE prank on his fans this past week.
Win the once in a lifetime chance to become our OFFICIAL gig reviewer as you see Little Mix up close in Manchester!
The X Factor boss and fellow judge Cheryl Fernandez-Versini praise the “loyal” chart-topping boyband who "love their fans".
The 'Uptown Funk' star says he thinks Taylor has an amazing shot at bagging the big one this Sunday.
He's young, rich and gorgeous and DAMN is he talented too. Check out 13 things Justin Bieber is better at then you.
Iggy Iggs says she hopes she can follow in Britney's footsteps and keep some normality despite her fame.
The 'Bang Bang' star is prepping another future hit fresh from #owning it on The Voice Australia.
Rita's revealed more about what we can expect from the as yet unheard song, 'Up', written for her by Ed Sheeran.