Love Island fans spot brutal forgotten detail in Elma and Curtis' All Stars row

12 February 2025, 12:34 | Updated: 12 February 2025, 17:25

Love Island All Stars fans have called the cast hypocritical for ignoring two things Elma said when arguing with Curtis.

Things have been heating up on Love Island All Stars and we aren't just talking about the South African sun. Producers added in a brand new feature in which the islanders could directly ask the public yes or no questions about their own couple and the other couples.

After sitting down for a meal of steak and chips, the revelations led into heated rows among multiple islanders - with Luca Bish cleverly trying diffuse arguments by jesting, "there's enough beef on the table".

But the episode ended with Elma Pazar and Curtis Pritchard getting heated over Elma and Sammy Root asking the public if Curtis and Ekin-Su were the weakest couple. The result came back in favour of Curtis and Ekin with 65% voting no and just 35% answering yes.

When the result was revealed, Elma turned to Curtis and said: "So the question did need to be asked Curtis, f--- off mate."

• Read more: Dumped Love Island All Stars islanders set to return to villa for major twist
• Read more: How big is Love Island's Elma and Sammy's age gap?
• Listen Now: Catch all the latest gossip from the Villa on the Love Island: The Morning After podcast on Global Player

Elma and Curtis row over dinner on Love Island: All Stars

When her response was met with disdain by her fellow islanders, she backtracked and said: "Well then, shut up is what I meant."

But now, as fans' start to turn on the Essex girlie they've said it's unfair that the villa didn't have a stronger reaction to her comments after they were upset at Harriett telling Casey O'Gorman to shut his "f---ing mouth" in an previous game.

Harriett's comments have even driven a wedge between her friendship with childhood bestie Luca, who told her he couldn't defend what she'd said.

Taking to X, one viewer said: "So Elma just said f--- off and shut up within thirty seconds of each other & everyone’s on mute? Justice for Harriet."

Someone replied to the post saying: "LITCH IM ACC FUMING".

They've also brought up how Grace Jackson has said it in arguments before, notably with Omar Nyame who she told to "shut the f--- up" during spin the bottle, but it hasn't been picked up by other islanders.

Commenters went on to bring up how Casey also refused to let Catherine Agbaje speak during the dinner and wasn't faced with criticism.

Someone wrote: "And Casey telling Catherine “No, I’m not letting you speak” when he cut her off after he asked them to explain and she was trying to… u can’t make this sh-- up".

It's safe to say it was an intense episode but some viewers think push back against Elma could come in tonight's episode as the show ended when she told Curtis: "If you want to find something to do, go and make a f---ing coffee, leave me alone."

Love Island All Stars continues tonight at 9pm on ITV2 and ITX.

Read more about Love Island here:

• Will Love Island All Stars have Casa Amor?
• Love Island All Stars 2025 ages: How old are the cast and who is the oldest?
• When is the Love Island All Stars 2025 final?
• Love Island's Jess White claps back at hate for teasing bombshell entrance

Listen live to Capital, and catch up on any shows you missed, on Global Player.

Listen to Love Island: The Morning After